Thread:Masked Vampire/@comment-5038193-20200211161249/@comment-45033623-20200211161754

Looking at the category's history, it seems like the problem was the anything goes approach to the category. People were allowed to add the character to any character they wanted, regardless of whether or not the character was actually close to being bad enough. Villains wiki used to have a lot of bother with the category but they upped the ante so characters have to be proposed before they can be added. Here's a recent proposal to give you an idea  https://villains.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:DeltaHorizon020/PE_Proposal:_Da_Ji

Why not try restoring the Pure Evil category but make it so users have to actually makes a proposal explaining who the character is, what they do, etc?